In a landmark judgment, the Supreme
Court of India has ruled that Watching Child Sexual Abuse Material (CSAM)
constitutes a criminal offense. This ruling has been a significant development
in India's fight against child exploitation and digital crimes. The judgment
emphasizes that the consumption of such materials is not a passive act but one
that perpetuates the demand for child abuse, contributing to a larger cycle of
exploitation. This article delves into the background, reasoning, and
implications of this pivotal decision.
.jfif "Supreme Court's Landmark Ruling: Watching Child Sexual Abuse Material is a Crime")
The Context: Child Sexual Abuse and the Internet
In recent years, the internet has
become a hub for a variety of crimes, including the distribution and
consumption of child sexual abuse material. Technological advancements,
especially in smartphones, high-speed internet, and encrypted platforms, have
made it easier for individuals to access and share illegal content. Child
sexual abuse material is a particularly heinous crime as it involves the
exploitation of the most vulnerable members of society — children.
India has been grappling with the
growing issue of CSAM, and the scale of the problem is alarming. According to
National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB) statistics, cases involving child
pornography and sexual exploitation of children have seen a sharp rise, with
digital platforms playing a significant role in facilitating the spread of such
material.
While possessing or distributing
child pornography has long been illegal under various laws, including the
Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act, the legal framework
surrounding the act of merely watching or consuming CSAM has been more
ambiguous until this Supreme Court ruling.
Supreme Court's Stand: Passive Viewing is Active Participation
The Supreme Court’s ruling clarifies
a crucial legal grey area — the question of whether simply watching or viewing
CSAM should be treated as a crime. The Court ruled unequivocally that the mere
act of watching such material, without any intent to store or distribute it,
also constitutes a criminal offense.
The bench, headed by Chief Justice
of India, stressed that watching CSAM is not a "victimless" crime. By
viewing such material, individuals are contributing to the continued
exploitation of children. The Supreme Court stated that the demand for CSAM
incentivizes abusers to continue creating and distributing such materials,
trapping more children in cycles of abuse.
Justice A.B. Sharma, who authored
the judgment, remarked, "Every click on such material fuels a dark
industry that thrives on the abuse and exploitation of innocent children. We
cannot allow perpetrators to escape under the guise of 'passive viewing' when
their actions directly contribute to the demand for child abuse."
Legal Framework and Provisions
India already has strict laws
governing the protection of children and the prohibition of child sexual abuse
material, but the Supreme Court’s ruling adds a new dimension to the
application of these laws.
- Information Technology Act, 2000 (IT Act): Under Section 67B, it is illegal to publish,
transmit, or cause to be transmitted any material depicting children in
sexually explicit acts, but it did not explicitly mention the criminality
of "watching" such material. The SC’s interpretation now implies
that viewing this material falls under the same category of criminal
behavior as producing or distributing it.
- Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act
(POCSO), 2012: POCSO criminalizes various
forms of sexual exploitation of children, including pornography. The act,
particularly under Section 13, mentions the prohibition of using children
for pornographic purposes. However, it was less explicit about the
consumption of such materials. The SC ruling strengthens POCSO’s mandate
by expanding its scope to include viewers of child pornography as active
participants in the crime.
- Indian Penal Code (IPC), 1860: Various sections of the IPC, including Sections 292
and 293, criminalize obscene content and its distribution. The Supreme
Court’s verdict links the consumption of obscene content involving
children to the broader framework of obscenity laws, reaffirming that CSAM
falls under this category.
The SC's ruling ensures that the law
will no longer turn a blind eye to those who consume CSAM, even if they are not
directly involved in its production or distribution.
Impact of the Ruling on Society and Law Enforcement
The Supreme Court’s ruling sends a
powerful message about the legal and moral responsibility that comes with
internet usage. The ruling is expected to have a wide-ranging impact on both
the judiciary and law enforcement.
Strengthening Legal Framework
This ruling expands the scope of
prosecutable offenses related to CSAM, making it clear that the mere act of
watching such material is punishable. Legal experts predict that this will lead
to amendments in existing laws, particularly the IT Act and POCSO, to
explicitly define "viewing" CSAM as a crime.
Additionally, the judgment is likely
to spur the Indian government into taking stronger action to regulate and
control the dissemination of CSAM on digital platforms. Stricter guidelines for
online platforms, including search engines, social media companies, and content
hosting services, will likely follow to ensure they do not become conduits for
such illegal content.
Challenges for Law Enforcement
While the ruling is a significant
step in combating child sexual exploitation, it also presents several
challenges for law enforcement. Tracking down individuals who view CSAM can be
more difficult than identifying those who distribute or produce it. Internet
activity is often protected by encryption, privacy laws, and international
boundaries, making it hard to trace.
Law enforcement agencies will need
to invest in more sophisticated technologies and international collaborations
to trace individuals involved in consuming CSAM. Collaboration with internet
service providers (ISPs) and tech companies will also be essential in tracking
down and prosecuting offenders.
Furthermore, the ruling may lead to
a flood of new cases, putting additional pressure on India’s already
overburdened legal system. Training and resources will need to be provided to
police, prosecutors, and judges to handle this new category of offenses
effectively.
The Role of Digital Platforms
In light of the Supreme Court
ruling, digital platforms will face increased scrutiny. Tech companies such as
Google, Facebook, Twitter, and other social media platforms will have to
implement stronger safeguards against CSAM. Automated tools to detect, report, and
remove such content, as well as stricter user policies, will become more
crucial.
The ruling also stresses the
importance of international cooperation. Since much of the internet content
transcends borders, collaboration between governments, law enforcement
agencies, and tech companies across different countries will be necessary to
curb the spread of CSAM.
The Larger Message: Morality and Responsibility in the Digital Age
The Supreme Court’s ruling
highlights an essential issue about the responsibilities of individuals in the
digital age. In a time when access to vast amounts of content is just a click
away, the court's judgment draws attention to the consequences of unethical
digital behavior.
By criminalizing the act of watching
CSAM, the court is reinforcing the idea that passive consumption is just as
harmful as active participation in child exploitation. The judgment serves as a
reminder that individuals bear a moral responsibility for their actions online.
Ignorance or passivity is no defense when it comes to contributing to an
industry that thrives on the exploitation of children.
Conclusion
The Supreme Court’s decision to
classify the viewing of child sexual abuse material as a criminal offense marks
a watershed moment in India’s battle against child exploitation. By holding
individuals accountable for their digital actions, the ruling aims to curb the
demand for CSAM and dissuade people from engaging with such material. The
decision is a clarion call for stricter regulations, better law enforcement,
and heightened societal awareness around the issues of child exploitation and
the internet.
However, the success of this ruling
will depend on how effectively it is implemented and enforced. It remains to be
seen how law enforcement agencies, digital platforms, and society at large will
respond to this legal shift. Nonetheless, this ruling is a step in the right
direction, aiming to protect the most vulnerable members of society and ensure
that the internet does not become a breeding ground for such heinous crimes.
The book is for you Discover by Dr. Keshav Kumar
- Excited to share my new book, The Hidden Fortune of 1857 Join detective Arjun and the clever Ruhi as they uncover a legendary treasure hidden in Delhi’s shadows, filled with dangerous traps and secrets from India’s past. Ready for a thrilling adventure?
- Dive into a transformative exploration of how global politics shapes the future of our planet. Dr. Kumar unveils the urgent need for sustainable governance that values all life on Earth, challenging traditional systems and offering a bold vision for change. If you’re passionate about the environment, justice, and a sustainable future, this book is for you!
📖 Read more about World Politics: Life of All Creatures here!
